Mainstay Inn      
635 Columbia Ave, Cape May, NJ 08204-2305, USA    
(609) 884-8690


  1. Mainstay Inn ...
  2. parlor...
  3. mirror...
  4. breakfast...
  5. The Windsor Room...
  6. The Bret Harte Room...
  7. The Henry Clay Room...
  8. The Cardinal Gibbons Room...
  9. inn...
  10. The Henry Sawyer Room...
  11. The Henry Ford Room...
  12. The President Harrison Room...

- $360

Book a Room $295 - $360

Send as Postcard

Visit Website


0 based on 0 reviews
See all Reviews
Write a Review

Tell the Innkeeper that
iLoveInns sent you!


Circa 1872. This was once the elegant and exclusive Jackson's Clubhouse popular with gamblers. Many of the guest rooms and the grand parlor look much as they did in the 1870s. Fourteen-foot-high ceilings, elaborate chandeliers, a sweeping veranda and a cupola add to the atmosphere. The Inn received the American Historic Inns award in 1988 for their preservation efforts, and have been making unforgettable memories for guests for decades. A writer for Conde Nast Traveler once wrote, "architecturally, no inn, anywhere, quite matches The Mainstay."

For more information visit the website.


$295 to $360

Off Season: $185 to $295

Payment Types Accepted Include Master Card, Travelers Checks, Personal Checks, Visa and CCs.

    • Breakfast
    • Snacks/Refreshments
    • Afternoon Tea


This property has 13 total guest accommodations, 12 with private bath, 3 suites and 1 guest house. The types of beds available include Double, Queen and King.

  • Air Conditioning
  • Bath Amenities
  • Bathrobes
  • Cable TV
  • Copy Machine
  • Fax
  • Hair Dryer
  • Iron/Ironing Board
  • Snack Bar
  • Television
  • Wireless Internet Access

Business Traveler Amenities

  • Desk
  • Television
  • Internet Access
  • Wireless Internet Access
  • FAX On-site
  • Iron/Ironing Board
  • Hair Dryer
  • Daily Newspapers
  • Gym Nearby

Events Hosted

    • Romantic Getaways
    • Family Reunions
    • Meetings
    • Seminars
    • Weddings

Spa Services

Off-Site Spa Services Available

Nearby Recommended Spas

Cape May Day Spa

Inns Of Interest

    • Cookbooks Written by Innkeepers

Pet Restrictions

  • Innkeepers pets on premises

Innkeepers Association Memberships

PAII, Select Registry

Reservation/Cancellation Policies:

Minimum Stay Requirements

3 days at peak times


We refund your deposit if we are able to re-book the opening your cancellation had made, minus a $35 processing fee


2pm / 11am


Smoke Free Property.

Other Activities

    • Antiquing
    • Art Galleries
    • Beaches
    • Bicycling
    • Canoeing/Kayaking
    • Fishing
    • Golf
    • Hiking
    • Horseback Riding
    • Live Theater
    • Museums
    • Parks
    • Shopping (Local Crafts)
    • Sports Events, Major College
    • Tennis
    • Water Sports
    • Wineries
    • Historic Attractions
    • Tennis
    • Golf
    • Birding
    • Biking
    • Hiking
    • Ocean Boardwalk

Historic Interest

Cape May Lighthouse & State Park Museum (2 miles).

Historic Awards:

  • National Register (Granted)
  • State Register (Granted)
  • Local Register (Granted)
  • National Historical Site (Granted)
  • State Historical Site (Granted)
  • City Historical Site (Granted)

Historic Memberships:

  • National Trust
  • Local Historical Society
  • National Landmark

Write a review

At A Glance

0 Review(s)
0% would stay again
Add your review

Very Good




Other Ratings: "3 AAA Diamonds, ""3 Mobil Stars, "iLoveInns Guests

Publicity and Press Reviews

Washington Post, Good Housekeeping, New York Times, Conde Nast Traveler, Smithsonian, Americana, Travel & Leisure, National Geographic Traveler.




Nearby Inns

Bedford Inn
805 Stockton Ave, Cape May, NJ (0.0 miles)
Rhythm of The Sea
1123 W. Beach Ave, Cape May, NJ (1.9 miles)
Elaine's Victorian Inn
513 Lafayette Street , Cape May, NJ (2.4 miles)
Wilbraham Mansion
133 Myrtle Ave, Cape May, NJ (2.4 miles)